
Repair or replace?
Extraction systems can run for many years if they are well designed and maintained, but not indefinitely. The decision is rarely about age alone. It is about whether the system still does its job safely, comfortably and compliantly at a reasonable cost.
Signs it may be time to replace
- The canopy is dented, corroded or no longer sits properly.
- Ductwork is damaged, heavily greased or cannot be cleaned because it has no access.
- The fan is noisy, vibrating or repeatedly failing.
- The kitchen is hot, smoky or smelly even with clean filters.
- The gas interlock keeps tripping or has been bypassed.
- Your cooking line has changed and the system was never sized for it.
- You cannot show design or commissioning records.
Changes that overload an old system
Adding a fryer, grill, wok range or charcoal oven, expanding the menu or increasing covers can overload a system designed for lighter use. HSE advises that where design data is absent for an existing installation, the installer should recommission the system and produce a report on its performance (CAIS10). A survey will show whether the existing canopy, fan and make-up air can cope.
Compliance and planning
If the system pre-dates current guidance or planning conditions, it may not meet them. A change of use or refit can trigger new requirements; see kitchen extraction regulations and planning permission.
Partial replacement
You do not always need to replace everything. Replacing filters, adding make-up air, fitting access doors, changing the fan or adding odour control can restore performance at lower cost. A survey identifies the most cost-effective route.
A simple repair-or-replace test
Ask four questions. Does the system still do its job safely and comfortably when clean and serviced? Can the canopy, ductwork and fan still be cleaned and maintained? Does it still match your appliances and menu? Do repair costs and downtime now exceed a sensible share of the cost of replacement? If the answer to any of the first three is no, or the fourth is yes, ask for a survey and a comparison of options.
Next step
Ask us to survey the kitchen: we measure airflow, inspect the canopy, ductwork and fan and recommend repair, modification or replacement. See kitchen extraction systems and our maintenance service.
Sources and further reading
Independent references we used, so you can check the rules yourself:
- HSE: Ventilation in catering kitchens (Catering Information Sheet 10)
- BESA (Building Engineering Services Association)
- legislation.gov.uk: Workplace (Health, Safety and Welfare) Regulations 1992
Frequently asked questions
How long does a commercial extraction system last?
There is no fixed life; it depends on design, use and maintenance. Condition and performance matter more than age.
Can I just replace the fan?
Sometimes, if the rest of the system is sound and the fan is the cause. A survey will confirm.
Do I need new drawings if I replace the system?
Yes. A replacement should be designed and commissioned, with records, rather than copied from the old one.
Can you survey an existing kitchen?
Yes, anywhere in the UK.


